Gayathri Saranathan Cong Xu Mahammad Parwez Alam Tarun Kumar Martin Foltin et al

Abstract

The rapid expansion of Large Language Models (LLMs) and natural language processing datasets has made exhaustive benchmark evaluations computationally prohibitive. Inspired by high-stakes competitions like the International Mathematical Olympiad-where a few well-chosen problems suffice to differentiate top performers—we present SubLIME, which reduces evaluation costs by 80% to 99% while preserving ranking fidelity. It trains a Rank Correlation Prediction (RCP) model that combines limited performance data from only 5-20 anchor LLMs with dataset intrinsic metrics - Difficulty, Quality, and Distributional Dispersion-to predict how closely a candidate subset reflects full-benchmark rankings. Guided by these predictions, SubLIME selects a “winning” subset (1-20% of full set data) for evaluating new LLMs, preserving global rankings significant better than other data-efficient methods across ten diverse benchmarks.